If most of the Linux distributions derive from either Slackware or Debian, why not just go to the source? Slackware looks way too hard to figure out, but Debian, which just released version 4.0, offers a net-install ISO — and I’ve always wanted to install a distro over the Internet — so I burned the CD this morning and am currently installing a Debian system over the Internet.
And it’s going very, very well, thank you. I didn’t know what to expect, but the installer is very much like that of Ubuntu’s alternate-install discs (not that I’ve gotten any of those to work, because I haven’t — my successful Xubuntu install came from the 6.10 live CD, upgraded to 7.04 over the Internet).
Debian, billed as “the universal operating system,” is currently installing 656 packages over the Internet, and after that I’ll see what the mother of many, if not most, Linux distributions is all about.
Update (12:27 p.m.): The install went without a hitch, and I’m now booting into Debian’s GNOME desktop.
Update (12:42 p.m.): I’m posting this update from Debian with the GNOME Web Browser 2.14.3 (also known as Epiphany). All seems to be working fine — I’ve got full functionality in Movable Type. There’s no Flash, of course, and it isn’t as easy to implement as in Xubuntu. But for now, I’ll leave Flash on the side of the road. I’m not that big of a YouTube fan.
My immediate first impression: This looks so nice and works so nice — it’s got GIMP, Open Office and the Iceweasel (aka Firefox) browser, GAIM and more. And what isn’t available as a Debian package?
Incidentally, during the install, I was given the option of making my /home file in a separate partition. I chose that option, since it might give me a way to reinstall this or another operating system in the main partition without disturbing the data in the /home partition. It might not work, but it’s worth a try.
Again, this install was just as easy as Ubuntu’s alternate install, and while having the advantage of actually working for me, I also appreciate that as an Internet-based install, I didn’t have to download a giant ISO file (the Debian net install ISO is 162, 716 KB) and as a bonus got the latest in all packages.
I was able to choose a “desktop” install, but nowhere was I asked about which window manager I wanted. GNOME is the default in this kind of network install. And I must say, it’s looking good and working well on this 1 GHz Maxspeed Maxterm thin client with 256 MB of RAM and a 14.4 GB IDE disk drive and 32x TDK CD-RW drive connected to the single IDE header on the mini-ITX motherboard.
This bears repeating, with emphasis: Installing Debian is no harder than Ubuntu. All my drives were automatically detected, just like Ubuntu. I’m beginning to wonder, just how much of Ubuntu is already there in Debian? It looks like a lot more than I thought.
Update (1:23 p.m.): I click on the GIMP. I’m surprised (and actually happy) to learn it’s not really there yet. An install window opens, in which I’m instructed to pick the amount of “tile memory” and the location of swap space for what won’t fit in tile memory. I accept the defauts, although I ‘m a bit nervous about the 128 MB I’m devoting to tile memory. But it’s nice to know that at least for some apps, those I’m not using are not taking up space on the drive. Oh, and the GIMP loads in 20 seconds — about a third of the time it took on Xubuntu 7.04. It’s something I could sure get used to. Update of this update: On second launch, GIMP takes 30 seconds to load (I must’ve needed to do some swapping with Open Office already up on another desktop.)
Obvious revelation: I discover something that most savvy Linux users probably already know. To navigate among the four available desktops in most environments, ctrl-alt-right arrow (or left arrow) sends you from one desktop to the other without need for the mouse. Brilliant. Four distinct desktops accesible via mouse or keyboard? I consider it a Linux killer app and wonder why Windows and OS X haven’t stolen the idea.
So far, GNOME in Debian 4.0 is no slower — AT ALL — then Xfce in Xubuntu 7.04. I still get the same “tiling” of windows when I drag them slightly off the desktop, but switching from app to app, window to window and desktop to desktop is as fast — if not faster — than it is on Xubuntu. And I’ll have to do that GIMP time test again with Xubuntu, because that would be a real difference between the two systems.
With Debian doing so well on this 1 GHz box with an anemic 133 MHz front-side bus and 256 MB of RAM, I can only imagine at this point how much better it could run on a more “modern” desktop, say something with a 3 GHz or dual-core processor, 1066 MHz FSB and 1 GB of RAM. It’s got to be great.
The next test: configuring a network printer. I went to Applications-System Tools-Printers, and just like in Ubuntu, a bunch of the printers on the network were detected automatically. I easily select one and successfully print with it. But … I try to add my “favorite” printer (i.e. the closest one to my desk) … and while the instructions are clear — and there are more of them than with Xubuntu — I am unable to make it happen. I go through all the steps, and at the end, after I click “Apply,” nothing is added, nor are there any messages telling me what went wrong. So I am able to print, just not exactly where I want. I was able in Xubuntu, after consulting the Xubuntu Users Guide, to get printing going through CUPS via the browser, and I imagine I could do the same here — and I just might. But I will give the Foomatic GUI another chance (or five) before I go that route. Update: I also try the utility under Desktop-Administration-Printing. While different, it still doesn’t work. But since I can print somewhere, I’m good for now.
Update (2:15 p.m.): At the top left of the GNOME screen, there are menus for Applications, Places and Desktop. The division of labor among the menus is a nice touch. There are tons of configuration utilities. I guess I’m talking more about GNOME than Debian at this point, but GNOME, in this implementation, is the face of Debian in this desktop distribution, and again, it’s done well.
Update (3:02 p.m.):Open Office Writer. It takes 1 minute, 3 seconds to launch. That’s one of the reasons I’m not so happy with Open Office. I know it’s doing all the things that MS Office can do, and that takes a lot of code, but all I need to do is create Word-compatible files (AbiWord can do that) with “typographical” or “smart” quotes (AbiWord can’t do that). Still, for what I’m doing these days, I can really leave typographical quotes on the roadside, so maybe I’ll try to install AbiWord just to have something that launches quickly and doesn’t hog so many resources.
Update of this update: On second launch, Open Office loads in 30 seconds. That I can live with.
Even so, I’ve pretty much been using text editors to write blog entries and the like, and when it comes to the Daily News, things for publication go through a translation program that takes care of the typographical quotes, so I don’t really need to be so anal about this … but I did have an editor (ther person, not the application) in the past who never got the punctuation right — quote marks, em dashes — unless I had it just so in Word, and even then he’d screw it up. I guess it all depends on your situation. Most editors of non-computer publications like to see things in Word format … though some are OK with pure text files. And creating and sending text files is just so quick and easy, I hope more publications move in that direction.
And speaking about text editors: I like gedit, the GNOME text editor. It looks a lot like Mousepad in Xfce, except that it’s got a nice toolbar and actually does the word-counting feature I need.
On a related point, I installed Scribus (open-source publishing program) in Xubuntu. I haven’t had a chance to use it yet, but I will if I ever hook up the hard drive with Xubuntu on it … or maybe I’ll just download it here in Debian.
Update (3:25 p.m.): Once the screen-saver takes over, why do I have to enter my password to bring the computer back to life?
Update (4:30 p.m.): I think I fixed the screen-saver problem. All I did was uncheck a box. That was easy.
Update: (4:45 p.m.): I’m using the GNOME music player, Rhythmbox and listening to one of the included Internet radio stations, this one called Groove Salad. And the audio is perfect. I couldn’t get audio this good from Puppy Linux. And the sound chip on the motherboard was detected and set up during the install and required no tweaking (OK, I lowered the volume a bit). Impressive. I switch to the Secret Agent “lounge” channel, which is more to my liking.
To sum up: I’ve run quite a few distros over the past three months, and with many being based on Debian, I’ve been led to believe that there’s something difficult about Debian, something that needed fixing for the “general Linux public,” whatever that is. So far, there’s no truth to that. Debian 4.0 is as ready for the desktop as any other distro out there — and by any other, I include Ubuntu and Mepis. Both of those are great, but Debian is running so well and is so easy to use, I wonder what the fuss over the others is all about.
Debian 4.0 is a great product, and if there was a lot of hype, I’d encourage you to believe it. As it is, with little hype (and a lot of negative news about the gap between releases and other developer squabbling), this is a very fine distribution that every Linux user should try. It sets a standard that others should live up to.
Final words: Xubuntu Feisty would not turn my system all the way off. Drives would spin down, but the power light remained on. No such problems in Debian 4.0.