Wolvix Hunter 1.1.0 image from Wolvix.org.
After dual-booting Ubuntu (at times 7.04 and 7.10) and Debian (first Etch, then Lenny, then a couple of Lennies for a couple of days) on the $0 Laptop (Gateway Solo 1450), I’ve said goodbye to Ubuntu for the time being and decided to install the dependable Wolvix Hunter 1.1.0 (the bigger of the two Wolvix distros) and keep Debian (still Lenny). After “losing” two Ubuntu 7.10 installs to unknown causes — both times processes began slowing to a crawl — I thought rolling back to Ubuntu 7.04 would give me something stable.
But the boot process for 7.04 began stalling at something having to do with the CD drive (I turned off “quiet spash” in GRUB so I could see where it was dying). I’m thinking that either my laptop or Ubuntu itself must be somehow cursed. One of the reasons I had Ubuntu installed, besides the fact that it works pretty well (when it does work) with this laptop, is that I can easily get Internet Explorer (via IEs4Linux) on the box. There’s one Web site I work on that absolutely requires IE, and my need for such access could grow from minimal to critical at just about any time. That hasn’t happened yet. What I’d like to see is updated instructions at IEs4Linux to get it set up on Debian. (As far as Debian goes, IEs4Linux remains stuck in the Sarge era).
But suffering through three dead Ubuntu installs in a row has made me weary. For one thing, I’m going back to separate partitions for /home. That’s how I have Wolvix set up. Wolvix can be run as a live CD, a frugal install or a full install. I believe the frugal install saves files in the same way as Knoppix and Damn Small Linux, and I want to be able to access the partition when booting Debian, so I opted for the full install. I don’t think Wolvix provides updates in the way Debian, Ubuntu and other “established” distros do. No matter. It runs even better on this laptop than it did on the Maxspeed Maxterm thin client (where Wolvix was tested along with another crop of distros in my gOS comparison).
And Wolvix has another thing going for it: It’s a Slackware-based distro that actually installs and runs with no trouble. Slackware 12 runs … but I just can’t get the X configuration right (and just about any other Slack-based distro offers a better Xfce experience in terms of applications and tools than Slackware itself, which remains a KDE-focused distro, albeit a faster KDE distro than any other). Both Zenwalk and Vector have been problematic; I can install, but something funky happens during booting and I can’t even get to a console. I suppose I could turn off ACPI, AGP, IRQs and the like … but if Wolvix can just run, why not the others? I probably will try to put Slackware 11 on the box at some point just to see if it’s Slackware 12 that’s screwing me over (Wolvix is based on Slack 11).
Anyhow, besides the fact that it runs and installs seamlessly, I really like the look of Wolvix, as well as the software mix in Wolvix Hunter (which features heavier apps like Open Office and the GIMP, along with lighter ones such as MtPaint, AbiWord and Dillo). Wolvix ships with Xfce and Fluxbox as window managers. In my recent tests, I’ve determined that Fluxbox doesn’t provide much of a speed advantage over Xfce, and since Xfce has many more features, I’m pretty much running it exclusively, even on the aged $15 Laptop (a 1999 Compaq Armada 7770dmt with a 233 MHz processor and 64 MB of RAM). And while the spread between Xfce and Fluxbox isn’t as wide as one would think, Xfce does provide significant speed advantages over GNOME and KDE
The Wolvix Control Panel app is excellent. For everything from configuration to installation, Wolvix is way ahead of most of the distributions I’ve used. While the network-configuration portion of the control panel can be somewhat confusing (it reminds me of Zenwalk), it does work. Before I figured it out, I tried using Slackware’s netconfig utility in Wolvix. It doesn’t seem to work, though you can go through the paces. At least Wolvix offers a utility that does work. With a distro like the highly touted gOS offering NO network configuration utility (they think everybody has DHCP), I’m thankful for any kind of help. Yes, I can hack the text files that hold Linux’s network configuration, but I’d prefer not to. It’s just the way I am.
Since I’m constantly switching between a static IP at the office and dynamic IP at home, it’s taking me a few extra steps (I love being able to easily switch between network settings in Debian and Ubuntu), but the trade-off is worth if since Wolvix otherwise performs so well.
And the Debian Lenny honeymoon is way, way over for me. I’ve considered rolling it back to Etch. My Alps touchpad issues are coming back (it’s not as perfect as it is in Wolvix, Ubuntu 7.04 or 7.10), and the fact that the new Lenny kernel seemed able to manage the noisy Gateway CPU fan for a day but not thereafter is very troubling. I can continue to use the Etch kernel with Lenny, and I just might do that, but I’m left wondering what’s going on and whether or not there’s an easier fix.
What I did do, for both Wolvix AND Debian Lenny, was put my fan-managing cron job to work. It basically checks CPU temp every five minutes and, if it goes above 60C, turns the fan on, then turns it off when it goes below 50C. Rather than a shell script and a cron job, I’d just like a single line of code that I could stick in some config file to make this work. I’ve seen things similar to what I need, but I haven’t yet nailed it down for the Gateway Solo 1450.
I did, however, get the fan to stop in Debian from boot (using @reboot as the time element for the entry in crontab for the first instance of the cron job, then following with */5 * * * * to run it every five minutes thereafter. Again, I will detail the Gateway Solo 1450 fan-control solution, step by step, in a future entry.
And while I think a cron job is a sloppy, hackish way to deal with a CPU fan, I’ve done it now in Puppy, Wolvix and Debian, so I’m pretty much getting used to it. It’s notable that in Ubuntu 6.06 LTS, I couldn’t get the system to allow me to turn the CPU fan on and off, even when sudoing the command. I guess I needed to write to root’s crontab, and sudoing can’t quite qet you there. At least that’s my six-second analysis of the situation. I would’ve loved to put Ubuntu 6.06 LTS on the laptop — perhaps it could stick around without self-destructing like 7.10 and 7.04. I seem to remember Ubuntu, at least in the alternate install, offering to create a root account. Maybe if I install with the alternate CD, I can get control of the fan. But do I really want to run Ubuntu 6.06 LTS?
Briefly, here is where Ubuntu is falling down:
$ sudo echo 3 > /proc/acpi/fan/FAN0/state
yields the following:
bash: /proc/acpi/fan/FAN0/state: Permission denied
In every other distro on which I’ve used this line in my cron job, I need to su to root to run it (Puppy logs you on as root, so it’s no problem there). But I can’t seem to get it to work in Ubuntu. As it is, 6.06 LTS only has five months of support remaining still has a year and five months of support remaining (I’m no math whiz). Might as well wait until 8.04 comes out as the next LTS (or just stick with CentOS 5). … Then again, Ubuntu 6.06 is from the Debian Sarge era. I smell another install of MepisLite 3.3 .. or maybe the recently updated — even though I thought it was dead — Sarge itself. I could always try to solve my Alps touchpad problems and stop my whining (if only …).
UPDATE: I figured out how to shut the fan on and off in Ubuntu. Details tomorrow morning.
I did keep Debian Lenny (upgraded from Etch). And I know this is the testing distribution and not stable, but I was alarmed by a bug I discovered in the Nautilus file manager. When in a Nautilus window, if you right-click on a file and try to get its properties, Nautilus crashes, a bug report screen comes up, and then Nautilus relaunches. I filled out the bug report and went to the Web page for the bug. While there are about 500 reports of the same bug, it looks like the bug itself has been “closed.” Well, it’s not fixed, but the report is closed. It says that the bug goes away in Gnome 2.20.1. I have 2.20.2, and it hasn’t gone away. I’m hoping that it will, but if the problem with the Ted word processor being catastrophically broken in both Etch and Lenny is any indication, I won’t hold my breath. I guess I don’t quite understand how bugs are dealt with.
As I said, I’m considering rolling it back to Etch. I’m also considering an installation of CentOS 5.0, which manages the CPU fan fine. Pros: CentOS, a copy of Red Hat Enterprise Linux, will be supporting this distro for YEARS; if it works now, it’ll get security patches for a long, long time. Cons: it’s harder — at least for me — to find as much variety in software as there is for Debian, Ubuntu, even Slackware. I’m sure there’s plenty of software out there — and there’s nothing stopping me from compiling my own — but I just couldn’t get the hang of adding repositories and GPG keys. Just finding and installing AbiWord was beyond my capabilities. Perhaps a RHEL 5 book would help me; they’ve got to be out there. Another con: RHEL — and, by extension , CentOS — doesn’t play MP3s or even Ogg audio files. I’m sure the codecs are out there, but I like the fact that most Linux distros — whatever philosophy of freedom they espouse — at least play an MP3. Hell — I even can play Oggs in Windows Media Player on my XP box.
But what I did do with Lenny today was pack a bunch of software onto it. I threw all the kids’ educational stuff I could find, the GIMP (I can’t believe Debian doesn’t ship with the GIMP), plus digiKam, which the esteemed Carla Schroder recommended to me as the best Linux image editor — one that also deals with the IPTC caption info that I need to both preserve and edit. (Both the GIMP, as well as Krita and MtPaint not only won’t edit the IPTC text embedded in a JPEG by Photoshop, they completely erase the info; NOT NICE.)
By the way, I thought about doing a frugal install of Puppy Linux, but what I did was preserve my pup_save on the Debian partition so I can continue running Puppy from CD (I’m still on 3.00; I’ve had no problems, so I haven’t tried the 3.01 CD yet, although I do have it).
I wish Damn Small Linux would run better on the Gateway, but I’m still running DSL 4.0 on the older $15 Laptop (Compaq Armada 7770dmt). There are new releases of DSL in the 4 series and also in the 3 series. I have to say that I like both of them. I did a lot of work with DSL 3.2 and 3.3, and I’m glad the developers are keeping both going. I am disappointed, however, that the version of Firefox (it’s 1.0.something) in DSL does not work with Google Docs. I was hoping to run DSL instead of Debian Etch (the main distro on the Compaq’s puny 3 GB hard drive) and gain some speed in Google Docs, but it is not to be. For better or worse, it’s another point in Puppy’s favor — Puppy’s Seamonkey browser/e-mail/HTML-generator app can handle Google Docs. But now that both Puppy and DSL feature MtPaint, at least they’re equal in terms of image editing; for me, MtPaint is the best lightweight image editor for Linux. If it edited the IPTC info, I’d be in geek heaven. Since it doesn’t, I remain on geek terra firma.
And I continue to prefer Geany as a text editor over DSL’s Beaver (and over Xfce’s Mousepad, GNOME’s Gedit, anything that comes with KDE … should I go on?).
I’m having one problem with Puppy: One of the Web sites I work on — LA.com — has an obscene amount of Flash animation, and it crashes Seamonkey every time I try to access it. I thought that Firefox might make a difference, so I installed the PET package. But the site crashes Firefox, too. I don’t have this problem in any other Linux distro or in Windows or Mac, so something fishy is going on. Yeah, the amount of Flash is obnoxious, but it’s not my call.
This entry is way too long, and I didn’t even mention my re-flirtation with PC-BSD. After I deleted Ubuntu and before I put Wolvix on the laptop, I decided to do another PC-BSD install. The install itself went fine. I still had that weird graphic blob below the cursor. And I downloaded three PBI files to update my 1.4 release (I didn’t feel like burning a new CD, since’s I’ve only got two left in my formerly 100-CD stack). One PBI took it from 1.4 to 1.4.1, the next to 1.4.1.1, and the last to 1.4.1.2. They couldn’t do this in a regular software update? Anyway, I couldn’t go from 1.4.1.1 to 1.4.1.2 — it said something about only updating from 1.4.1. And BSD is different enough from Linux that the prospect of adapting my fan-quieting cron job to BSD is and will remain way beyond my capabilities.
So PC-BSD met the same fate as it did the last few times I installed it; it came down quickly. I’m enjoying Wolvix Hunter right now.
So here’s where I stand this week with the $0 Laptop: Wolvix Hunter 1.1.0 and Debian Lenny on the hard drive (Wolvix with its own /home, so I can roll a new distro over it without killing out my files) and Puppy 3.00 as a live CD. But I’m thisclose to slapping Ubuntu 6.06 LTS or CentOS 5.0 in there.
Like many of you, I’m stuck between changing Linux and BSD distributions like underwear and finding something that can serve me for years without it either falling apart or me yearning for something better.
Takectrl's Weblog 